Ayna Klinik Psikoloji Dergisi; 2014;1(1):26-40
Yetişkin Bağlanma Biçimleri ile Obsesif-Kompulsif Bozukluk Arasındaki İlişkinin İncelenmesi: Psikoterapi Uygulamasına Bir Örnek
FÖ Üncüer
Orta Doğu Teknik Üniversitesi, Ankara
Obsesif-kompulsif bozukluk (OKB), bireylerin işlevselliğinde gözle görülür bozulmaya sebep olan
oldukça yaygın anksiyete bozukluklarından biridir. Bilişsel modellere göre OKB semptomlarının şiddetlenmesinde,
istem dışı girici (intrusif) düşüncelerin işlevsel olmayan inançlar sonucunda hatalı olarak
yorumlanması ve bu düşüncelere atfedilen önem, önemli bir rol oynamaktadır. İşlevsel olmayan
inançların oluşumunda rol oynayan bağlanma örüntüsü ve ebeveyn tutumları gibi gelişimsel faktörlerin
incelenmesi ve altta yatan süreçlerin de anlaşılmasıyla birlikte bilişsel modeller temelinde oluşturulan
tedavi yöntemlerinin geliştirilebileceği öne sürülmektedir. Bu makalede, bazı temel terminolojik
açıklamalarla birlikte, obsesif-kompulsif belirtiler ile kişilerin bağlanma örüntüleri ve benlik algıları
arasındaki ilişki ampirik çalışmalardan elde edilen bulgular ve klinik deneyim bazında incelenmiştir.
Son kısımda ise, OKB tanısı ile takip edilen bir vaka anlatılarak, bu konunun psikoterapi açısından
önemi ve uygulamanın nasıl yapılacağı tartışılmıştır.
A Review of The Contributions of Adulthood Attachment Orientations to Development of Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder: An Illustration of Psychotherapy Integration
Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) is one of the most disabling and highly prevalent
anxiety disorders. Cognitive models of OCD propose that negative evaluation of intrusions occur
as a consequence of underlying maladaptive beliefs, such as inflated responsibility, overestimation
of threat, intolerance for uncertainty, perfectionism, the need to control thoughts, and over-importance
of thoughts. Although cognitive models have enhanced the knowledge and treatment of
OCD, they have been criticized for focusing largely on maintaining and exacerbating factors of
OCD-related beliefs and neglecting the developmental and motivational factors, such as early
attachment and parenting behaviors (Doron & Kyrios, 2005; O'Kearney, 2001). It is argued that
consideration of underlying vulnerabilities, such as attachment insecurities and early experiences
of parenting may lead to a broader understanding of the development and maintenance of OCD-related
beliefs and symptoms. Thus, the current paper consists of four main parts reviewing the roles
of attachment insecurities, self-views, and parental attitudes in the development of obsessive-compulsive
symptomatology. In order to demonstrate the importance of understanding these factors
while dealing with a patient having OCD, the case of Ms. D. is illustrated. Ms. D., who is directed
into our clinic with the diagnosis of obsessive-compulsive disorder, is a 21 years old, second-year
university student. Her obsessions have involved the theme of contamination and that her entire
body would be invaded by germs. In response to these obsessions, her compulsions have involved
washing hands, using disinfectants, and cleaning the furniture in her house with a rigid routine
after coming from the outside.
Following the discussion of some basic terminological issues about attachment system and
adult functioning, the current paper proceeds to a review of the association between OCD-related
symptoms, patient’s attachment insecurity, and perception of self based on both findings of empirical
studies and experiences obtained from clinical practice. The evidence indicates that attachment
insecurities together with other early influences, such as parental overprotection, can contribute to
the development of main schemas in OCD (e.g. inflated sense responsibility, overestimation of
threat, perfectionism etc.), which in turn result in obsessive-compulsive symptoms. The evidence
also indicates a link between attachment representations, sensitive self-structures perceptions of
others and the world, and obsessive-compulsive phenomena. Likewise, it is important to note that
the sense of attachment security may play a protective role against OCD-related processes of the
activation of feared self-cognitions and dysfunctional beliefs following events that challenge self
domains (Doron et. al., 2009). Moreover, in order to reject the negative self and overemphasize the
positive self, the child develops specific schemas including perfectionism, need for certainty, or
inflated responsibility, which is accepted as the core vulnerability in OCD. Additionally, these
schemas are reinforced by the inflexible and controlling attitudes of parents concerning morality
and responsibility (Kempke & Luyten, 2007). Clearly, the theoretical link between attachment
types, internal representations of self and vulnerability in OCD offers a potentially rich area for
intervention. The knowledge of attachment insecurities in relation to development of OCD-related
beliefs is particularly helpful to psychotherapists in their practices (Liotti, 2011). Therefore, at
times of facing with resistance, this knowledge could assist therapists to explore whether the
present adversity grounded in the activation of implicit attachment interactions and distorted sense
of self in therapeutic relationship. It is explained in detail by giving examples from the relationship
between Ms. D. and her therapist. The focus of the therapy with Ms. D. and the nature of therapeutic
relationship is discussed in the psychotherapy part of the article. Finally, it can be concluded
that enhancing the conceptualization of cognitive models of OCD with the understanding of
developmental factors would provide a useful framework about mental representations that negatively
influencing patient’s cognitions and symptomatic behaviors.
AYNA Klinik Psikoloji Dergisi
2014, 1(1), 26-40 Filiz Özekin Üncüer
Summary
A Review of The Contributions of Adulthood Attachment Orientations to Development of
Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder: An Illustration of Psychotherapy Integration
Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) is one of the most disabling and highly prevalent
anxiety disorders. Cognitive models of OCD propose that negative evaluation of intrusions occur
as a consequence of underlying maladaptive beliefs, such as inflated responsibility, overestimation
of threat, intolerance for uncertainty, perfectionism, the need to control thoughts, and over-importance
of thoughts. Although cognitive models have enhanced the knowledge and treatment of
OCD, they have been criticized for focusing largely on maintaining and exacerbating factors of
OCD-related beliefs and neglecting the developmental and motivational factors, such as early
attachment and parenting behaviors (Doron & Kyrios, 2005; O'Kearney, 2001). It is argued that
consideration of underlying vulnerabilities, such as attachment insecurities and early experiences
of parenting may lead to a broader understanding of the development and maintenance of OCD-related
beliefs and symptoms. Thus, the current paper consists of four main parts reviewing the roles
of attachment insecurities, self-views, and parental attitudes in the development of obsessive-compulsive
symptomatology. In order to demonstrate the importance of understanding these factors
while dealing with a patient having OCD, the case of Ms. D. is illustrated. Ms. D., who is directed
into our clinic with the diagnosis of obsessive-compulsive disorder, is a 21 years old, second-year
university student. Her obsessions have involved the theme of contamination and that her entire
body would be invaded by germs. In response to these obsessions, her compulsions have involved
washing hands, using disinfectants, and cleaning the furniture in her house with a rigid routine
after coming from the outside.
Following the discussion of some basic terminological issues about attachment system and
adult functioning, the current paper proceeds to a review of the association between OCD-related
symptoms, patient’s attachment insecurity, and perception of self based on both findings of empirical
studies and experiences obtained from clinical practice. The evidence indicates that attachment
insecurities together with other early influences, such as parental overprotection, can contribute to
the development of main schemas in OCD (e.g. inflated sense responsibility, overestimation of
threat, perfectionism etc.), which in turn result in obsessive-compulsive symptoms. The evidence
also indicates a link between attachment representations, sensitive self-structures perceptions of
others and the world, and obsessive-compulsive phenomena. Likewise, it is important to note that
the sense of attachment security may play a protective role against OCD-related processes of the
activation of feared self-cognitions and dysfunctional beliefs following events that challenge self
domains (Doron et. al., 2009). Moreover, in order to reject the negative self and overemphasize the
positive self, the child develops specific schemas including perfectionism, need for certainty, or
inflated responsibility, which is accepted as the core vulnerability in OCD. Additionally, these
schemas are reinforced by the inflexible and controlling attitudes of parents concerning morality
and responsibility (Kempke & Luyten, 2007). Clearly, the theoretical link between attachment
types, internal representations of self and vulnerability in OCD offers a potentially rich area for
intervention. The knowledge of attachment insecurities in relation to development of OCD-related
beliefs is particularly helpful to psychotherapists in their practices (Liotti, 2011). Therefore, at
times of facing with resistance, this knowledge could assist therapists to explore whether the
present adversity grounded in the activation of implicit attachment interactions and distorted sense
of self in therapeutic relationship. It is explained in detail by giving examples from the relationship
40
between Ms. D. and her therapist. The focus of the therapy with Ms. D. and the nature of therapeutic
relationship is discussed in the psychotherapy part of the article. Finally, it can be concluded
that enhancing the conceptualization of cognitive models of OCD with the understanding of
developmental factors would provide a useful framework about mental representations that negatively
influencing patient’s cognitions and symptomatic behaviors.