Ayna Klinik Psikoloji Dergisi; 2014;1(1):13-25
Çocuklukta Cinsel İstismar ve Buna Bağlı Duygusal Bastırma: Yetişkinlerle Psikoterapi Süreci ve Sürecin Terapiste Etkileri
PÖ Çağlayan
Orta Doğu Teknik Üniversitesi, Ankara
Bu çalışmanın amacı, travmatik yaşam olaylarından kaynaklanan duygusal bastırmaya, bastırmanın
travma mağdurlarına etkilerine, psikoterapi sürecinde izlenen tedavi yöntemlerine, ve psikoterapi
sürecinde travma hikayelerini dinleyen ve bunlarla çalışan terapistlerin duygularına değinmektir. Bu
makalede, Türkiye’de sıkça yaşanan ve uzun dönemde ruhsal problemlere yol açan travmaların başında
gelen çocukluk dönemi cinsel istismarına odaklanılmıştır. Yazar, travma ve duygusal bastırma hakkındaki
teorik bilgilerin psikoterapi süreciyle entegre edilerek sunulması amacıyla, çalışmakta olduğu bir
vakasını da bu makalede ele almıştır. Travma ile başa çıkabilmek amacıyla, duygularını bastıran
mağdurların olumsuz duygu durumlarının daha da arttığı göz önünde bulundurulduğunda, bu çalışmada
ele alınan vaka, bu konuya bir örnek teşkil etmektedir. Ayrıca, bu vaka, duygusal bastırmanın mağdurlar
üzerindeki olumsuz etkileri ile ilgili literatür bulgularını destekleyici ve açıklayıcı bir özelliğe sahiptir.
Çocukluk yıllarında cinsel istismara maruz kalan yetişkinlerle yürütülen psikoterapi sürecinde amaç,
mağdurun travmatik yaşantılarını anlatmasını, böylece, yaşadığı asıl duygularına ulaşmasını ve onları
gözden geçirerek ifade etmesini sağlamaktır. Çocuklukta cinsel istismar mağduru olan yetişkinlerle
sürdürülen psikoterapi sürecinde, terapistler de duygusal zorluklar yaşamaktadırlar. Bu zorluklar,
temsili travmatizasyon ve travmatik karşıaktarım şeklinde iki ana grupta ele alınmıştır. Psikoterapi
sürecinde, yaşadığı travma sonrasında duygusal bastırmaya başvuran mağdurların duygularını ele alan
terapistin, aynı zamanda kendi zorluklarını da ele alarak yoluna devam etmesi sürecin en önemli yapı
taşıdır. Bu çalışma, hem terapistin hem de hastanın duygularının üzerinde çalışılması gereken önemli
bir alana işaret etmektedir
Childhood Sexual Abuse and Emotional Suppression: Adult Psychotherapy Process and Effects on Psychotherapist
The purpose of the current article is to focus on emotional suppression in adult survivors of
childhood sexual abuse, which is one of the most frequent traumatic events in Turkey and the most
important leading causes of long term psychological problems in adulthood. The effects of emotional
suppression on trauma survivors, important aspects of therapy process and emotions of
therapists while listening and working on traumatic stories, are the main focus of this article. The
author illustrated one of her clinical cases by integrating the theoretical perspective and literature
findings about trauma and emotional suppression with the psychotherapy process.
In emotion perspective, as mental, physical, and behavioral reactions of individuals to
traumatic experiences, their emotional reactions are crucial. Feelings of fear, sadness, anger,
irritability, guilt, shame, loss of trust and self-esteem, and emotional distance from others are
important aspects of survivors’ emotional state. Furthermore, as Herman (1997) reported, emotional
blunting, emotional flooding, or change over these two extremes determined the emotional
behavior of trauma survivors. In terms of emotional behaviors of survivors, the emotion suppression
is one of the important coping strategies used to deal with negative impacts of the event.
However, the maladaptiveness of this coping strategy was revealed in the literature (Gross, 2007).
Accordingly, studies focusing on the mediation effect of emotional suppression, on the relationship
between trait of negative affect intensity and psychological distress, showed that the use of
suppression was related to higher intensity of negative emotions (Lynch, Robins, Morse, and
Krause, 2001). The case of childhood sexual abuse covered in this article is a representative
example of this condition.
In the therapy processs of trauma survivors, avoiding emotion expression and its causes are
important treatment target for this population (Kennedy-Moore and Watson, 1999; Rosenthall, et
al., 2005). The main aim of the therapy process is to make survivors disclose their traumatic
experiences, thus to process their original affective responses to trauma and memories of the
event. By doing so, therapist helped survivors realize their symptoms of emotion inhibition and
begin to appraise them (Kennedy-Moore and Watson, 1999).
On behalf of therapists, it was revealed that interacting with individuals who were using
expression suppression was rated as more stressful than interacting with individuals using reappraisal
(Butler, Egloff, Wilhelm, Smith, Erickson, and Gross, 2003). However, in case of childhood
sexual abuse, the difficulties therapists faced with while working with traumatic events and
trauma related emotions, deserve more attention than difficulties while working with emotion
suppression.
Accordingly, working with trauma survivors is a challenging issue in terms of therapists’
emotions. To hear and to witness negative experiences of survivors leaves some marks on therapists
who are attempting to care them (Wastell, 2005; Kaser-Boyd, n.d.). The difficulties they
experience during therapy process of sexual abuse were covered under two titles including vicarious
traumatization and traumatic countertransference.
To conclude, this paper is a discussion about the emotional suppression of clients who
were sexually abused in their childhood. The therapy process of these sexual abuse victims
includes therapist’s difficulties in dealing with clients’ feelings, especially helplessness and horror
and the treatment of survivors. In the literature, the emotional suppression was classified as a
coping strategy in order to deal with negative emotions resulted from traumatic experiences. However, it was associated with poor psychological health. Trauma victims suppressing their
feelings suffer from impaired memory of the event, physiological responsiveness, and high degree
of negative emotions. Moreover, they could not resolve the conflict between their actual inner
experience and outer expression of their emotions. Furthermore, the case of K. supported the
empirical findings about emotional suppression. Therefore, the maladaptiveness of emotional
suppression was justified by research findings and example of clinical experience of the author.